Danish Dari German Spanish French Turkish Arabic
Click here to go to start page Click here to go to start page
Search Sort content by country/region Sort content by artist Sort content by subject
News stories world-wide
News 2009
News 2008
News 2007
News 2006
News 2005
News 2004
News 2003
News 2002
News 2001
About music censorship
Artists on censorship
About Freemuse
Publications
Study room
Activities
Links
Press room

NEWS
15 April 2009

USA / United Kingdom:
American pop singer pressured to rerecord song

When American pop singer Britney Spears’ hit song ‘If U Seek Amy’ risked censorship on radio stations because of a controversy over its use of a ‘sexually offensive’ double entendre in the chorus, she decided to rerecord the song and publish a less offensive version.

Say it quickly: ‘If U Seek Amy’.
It sounds as ‘f. u. c. k. me’.

Radio stations across the United States and United Kingdom deemed the track too offensive to broadcast, and in response to the criticism — in order to avoid being blacklisted — Britney Spears announced in January 2009 that she would change the title and amend the allegedly offensive sections of the song.

A new radio edit single was created, entitled ‘If U See Amy’ where the 'k' in 'seek' had been muted and the chorus speeded up, resulting in a thirteen seconds shorter duration of the song.

The decision meant that the lyrics no longer made any sense, but “the realities of the global record industry meant that she was probably left with little alternative,” wrote The Independent.

The amended version of the song was released as the third single from Britney Spears’ platinum-selling album ‘Circus’ on 10 March 2009 in the US, and is to be released in the United Kingdom in May 2009.

The offensive lyrics
The original chorus line says:

    “All of the boys and all of the girls are beggin’
    to If U Seek Amy”

and in another part of the chorus, Britney sings:
    “Oh baby, baby, If You Seek Amy tonight
    Oh baby, baby, we'll do whatever you like”


Radio stations ‘irresponsible’
The private, non-governmental and self-appointed American media watchdog group The Parents Television Council was among the first to caution radio stations and cable music channels about broadcasting the song and the music video for this song.

The United Kingdom’s biggest radio station, BBC Radio 1, banned the song — something which prompted many fans to complain to the station.

An Australian mother’s group slammed the song as ‘horrifying’ and ‘objectionable’.

The Australian music site Undercover.com.au quoted parents as saying, “I was astonished and totally taken aback when I heard my 5 and 7 year old kids walking around the house singing ‘F-U-C-K’ ... When I asked them what it was, they told me it was Britney Spears. I was horrified.”

Angry parents were reported to have “swamped the Australian Family Association with complaints about risque hits on the radio,” which also includes the English pop singer Lily Allen’s songs, ‘Not Fair’ and ‘F*** You’.

Ken Francis, president of Australian Family Association Queensland, said the radio stations were being irresponsible:

“There are many parents who are concerned about what is being played on the radio. Radio has a responsibility for the wellbeing of children and teens who listen. I really don’t understand why those sexually explicit songs need to be played at all,” the Courier Mail quoted Ken Francis as saying.

Defended the song
Estelle Paterson of the Australian radio Nova 100 FM, said: “The Britney song isn’t swearing. It’s a cheeky play on words. If we had to ban that song until late evening, we’d have to do the same with most songs we play.”

The American magazine Rolling Stone defended Britney Spears, arguing that parents should have been aware of the singer's musical themes.






Sources

Thaindian News – 5 April 2009:

'Explicit Britney Spears, Lily Allen songs leave Oz parents livid'

The Independent – 21 January 2009:

''Squeaky-clean' Britney falls foul of lyric censors'

Wikipedia, the open encyclopedia – continously edited by its users:

'If U Seek Amy'


Go to top
Related reading on freemuse.org

USA: Banned music showcased in concert series in New York
A concert with the exiled Pakistani singer Haroon Bacha on 9 December 2009 marks the start of 'Impossible Music Sessions' in New York showcasing banned music
09 December 2009
USA: City council discusses ban on hip-hop
A councilman in Fort Myers, Florida, is seeking to have hip-hop music banned at the Harborside Events Center and other venues in Fort Myers
05 October 2009
USA / Jamiaca: Buju Banton has US tour canceled by promoters
US concert promoters canceled shows by Buju Banton after protests from gay rights advocacy organisations over the singer's homophobic song lyrics
07 September 2009
USA: American pop singer pressured to rerecord song
When American pop singer Britney Spears' hit song 'If U Seek Amy' risked censorship on radio stations because of a double entendre in the chorus, she rerecorded the song
15 April 2009
Pakistan/USA: Salman Ahmad: Obama should listen to Pakistani artists
As the Taliban silence music in the Swat Valley in northern Pakistan, Freemuse ambassador Salman Ahmad denounces the Pakistani peace accord with the Taliban
13 March 2009
Freemuse Award 2009: video report and interview from Stockholm
Video interview with Tao Rodriquez-Seeger who received the Freemuse Award on his grandfather's behalf on 3 March 2009
07 March 2009
Tao Rodriquez-Seeger
Video interview with singer and musician Tao Rodríguez-Seeger from USA who speaks about his personal experiences with music censorship
07 March 2009
Freemuse Award 2009
Singer, songwriter, activist, environmentalist, and peace advocate Pete Seeger receives the Freemuse Award 2009
26 February 2009
Human Rights for Musicians – Impressions & Descriptions: Stephan Said
Testimonial by Stephan Said in the anniversary publication 'Human Rights for Musicians - Ten Years With Freemuse'
30 January 2009
Iraq / USA: Interview with exiled oud player
Interview with Iraqi oud player and composer Rahim AlHaj - a former political prisoner of Saddam Hussein who escaped Iraq and relocated to the US, New Mexico, in 2000
26 November 2008
USA: Opera composer says he is 'blacklisted' by US authorities
Composer John Adams told BBC he is now 'blacklisted' and followed by US security forces because he wrote the controversial opera 'The Death of Klinghoffer'
23 October 2008
Commentary: Motley Crue, open your ears to Middle East bands
Author Mark LeVine asks the heavy metal band Motley Crue: "Why not really make rock history and open your Make Rock History contest to bands from around the world?"
01 August 2008
Kris Kristofferson
Video interview with American folk singer Kris Kristofferson about his personal experiences with music censorship in USA - and in Russia
31 March 2008
USA: Controversial lyrics lead to concert cancellation
British punk rock band Gallows were removed from the bill of The House Of Blues in California due to offence taken to their lyrics by the owner of the venue, the Disney Company
29 January 2008
Jamaica / USA: Boundaries of freedom of musical expression examined
The boundaries of free speech in today's popular music culture are to be examined in a tv programme recorded in New York, USA, on 7 February 2008
22 January 2008
Palestine: Islamist reactionary groups threaten American pop stars
Pop stars Madonna and Britney Spears will have their "heads cut off" if they continue "spreading Satanic American culture", threaten militant groups in Palestine
13 November 2007
USA: Lebanese musician denied use of theatre
Marcel Khalife often speaks for reconciliation, resulting in bans in the Middle East. Ironically one of his concerts was rejected in the US, accused of being "unbalanced".
14 October 2007
USA: Disney criticised for stopping heavy metal concerts
Why has the heavy metal genre now been labeled “inflammatory” and their fans “undesirable? at House of Blues venues in Anaheim and Orlando?
11 October 2007
USA: Gangsta rap condemned by local police
The police in Colorado Springs publicly condemned the music genre gangsta rap in a news release after a killing in July 2007, writes The New York Times
05 September 2007
USA: Music tv channel bleeps the word ‘suicidal’
The American rapper Sean Kingston was afraid to feel suicidally heartbroken. But MTV and some radio stations have chosen less dramatic versions of the summer hit.
28 August 2007