Britain at War “Broadcasters have a history of being sensitive about certain material. I think it is probably true to say that it is not a matter in Britain of the central state saying, “you can’t play this”. It is a matter of broadcasters saying, “we’re supporting our boys in this one, we’re not going to rock the boat””.
Extensive paper on freedom of musical expression in Britain during the Falkland and Gulf wars, presented at the 1st World Conference on Music and Censorship, Copenhagen 20-22 November, 1998, by Martin Cloonan, Ph.D., Researchfellow, University of Stirling, Scotland.
What I would like to do is to give you a taste of censorship in Britain. Britain is quite often seen as a place where censorship doesn’t occur but it certainly does. I will explain how the law works in Britain and then talk about broadcasting regulations and then come on to talking about the Golf war. Let me start with the legal situation in Britain. The legal situation in Britain is quite complicated because the constituent four countries in Britain have slightly differing laws about censorship. However the most important law which covers England and Wales is called the 1959 Obscene Publication Act. This covers obscene articles of all sorts, books, films, records etc.
The law bans material which would deprave and corrupt its likely audience. There have been cases where music has been held to have that capacity. It is a very controversial piece of legislation. It’s been on since 1959. There have been numerous debates about what to do with it. Let me just give you a taste of what happens should you be in the unfortunate position to be a musician who has become victim of this law. I will give you an example from 1991.
The police in Nottingham raided a record company called Earache Records which is a death metal and speed metal organisation. They raided the record plant and took away a lot of stock. What happens is that the police will raid and take your stock away. But they have to list the stock that they take away, and this is where it becomes very interesting. A list of stock ceased from Earache Records included stock by bands called The Filthy Christians, Carcass and various things. But it also has some wonderful things where the police get slightly paranoid so there are copies of newspapers among other things. My very favourite one is that they ceased an Alice Cooper poster complete with ‘blue-tack’. So they can presumably stick it on the wall in the police station. That material was held for about 16 months before it was returned to Earache Records, it was not actually prosecuted. That is the kind of thing that happens.
The situation in Britain is also complicated by the fact that censorship is not centralised. Local councils still have power over film and over licensing of venues and so on. Regional police forces have a great deal of autonomy, there is no national police force. So to an extent the type of censorship you are subject to in Britain depends on where you live. Most importantly of all, the British State has farmed out the broadcasting to the broadcasters themselves. Whilst there are legal restrictions upon what broadcasters can broadcast, essentially broadcasting is run by the interpretation of various rules.
The broadcasters in Britain are covered by the law but also their own regulations. Both the commercial stations and the state owned BBC Network have obligations not to offend taste and decency, this is written into their regulations. OK, so what’s taste and decency? I think we heard this morning that there is a very important role played by interpreters of regulations. Obviously at times of national crisis the definition of taste and decency tends to narrow a little. This is most obviously the case in times of war. One of the things that is quite obvious with censorship is that it is inexplicably linked to contemporary events. There is a sort of censorial climate which goes up and down. Certainly in times of war the censorial hate will come up. What has happened in Britain is that whenever there has been war, censorship has increased.
For example if you go back to the First World War there were censorship of musical songs. During the Second World War obviously the BBC was not particularly keen on playing German music. There were bans during the Falklands war for certain records. I think it would be fair to say that records that criticised the government policy during the Falklands war did not get a great deal of airplay. Of course the longest running saga of censorship in contemporary Britain was the war in Ireland. We heard this morning of Paul McCartney getting banned and there were various bands and records about the situation in Ireland.
So by the time we get to the Golf war in the early 1990s you can see the broadcasters have a history of being sensitive about certain material. I think it is probably true to say that it is not a matter in Britain of the central state saying, “you can’t play this”. It is a matter of broadcasters saying, “we’re supporting our boys in this one, we’re not going to rock the boat”. The broadcasters has a somewhat ambiguous role during the Golf war. At one level, a whole BBC Radio station was devoted to coverage of the Golf war, minute by minute, 24 hours a day. They kind of separated the Golf war from main stream broadcasting. I think what effectively happened was that popular entertainment, popular music was not allowed to impinge on the war. Even though Radio One, the main broadcasting station, went out to the Golf and broadcasted from there, there was still a sort of mental separation that popular entertainment must carry on regardless of the war. So what happened was that during the run up to the Golf war on commercial radio, on Jazz FM, a man called Gilles Peterson decided that as the United Nations deadline for action against Iraq was coming close he would play two hours of peace music. Fairly impartial, one would have thought, just to play music calling for peace. The result of that was that he was sacked, he was deemed to have broken broadcast regulations for displaying political partiality. Independent commercial radio in Britain is supervised by the Radio Authority. When complaints were made to the authority about the sacking of Gilles Peterson for playing peace music they said that it was an internal matter, it is just what the station decides itself. However, they upheld complaints against Jazz FM for not being politically impartial.
Meanwhile back at Radio One and back at the BBC a famous list of records was produced. What happened was that this list of records was not a ban as such it was just a list of records produced which BBC producers and DJ’s might like to consider carefully before playing. This is not a ban, it was produced by local radio within BBC. Just a few examples from this list. It says, “Be very careful about playing these records during the Golf war”: ABBA: Waterloo, Kate Bush: Army Dreamers, José Feliciano: Light my Fire, Queen: Killer Queen, 10CC: Rubber Bullets. I think in retrospect one of the things that this ridiculous list of records did, because it got quite a lot of press, was actually to make the war thing less important. Whatever the persons making this list intended I think in Britain it made the war seem less serious than it was.
We heard some talk today about musicians having a history of resistance. During the Golf war in Britain I think it was very hard to resist the war and not be tainted with being a supporter of Saddam Hussein. It was very hard politically to do that. There was a group called Musicians Against the War, which was formed. It got almost no press and I think apart from holding a singing outside the BBC to protest against this list, its overall impact I would say was nil. There were other sorts of petty acts of censorship during the Golf war. During the annual Brit Awards for music in 1991 the artists who appeared on that show were told not to mention the war. Artists who broke that rule, including people like Lisa Stansfield, who said when she was receiving the award, “This award is very nice but it would be a much better reward for me if the war stopped”, received a great deal of media hostility straight away. Sinead O’Connor also spoke out against the war and boycotted the Brit Awards that year. She found that instead of a video of Nothing Compares To You being shown, that they showed a video of Whitney Houston singing Star Spangled Banner as a direct insult to Sinead O’Connor who had been protesting against having the American National Anthem played at a concert. So all sorts of petty spite going on.
Within the record industry they knuckled down as well, saying we don’t want to rock the boat here, we don’t want to offend people. Forget the fact that the British Army is out there slaughtering Iraqis. So they asked bands to change their names, Massive Attack became Massive, The Happy Mondays have a song called Loose Fit which talks about blowing up an airport base, that line was dropped from the song when the single was released. A band called Carter the Unstoppable Sex Machine had a record called Blood sports for all which is a critique of racism within the British Army. The record company made them swap that and put it on the B-side of the single during the Golf war. So there are various sorts of petty censorship going on. So I think that overall this is not the sort of central state saying, “you must do this”, there is a kind of atmosphere where you don’t rock the boat. The context of all this is that the BBC was being accused of being left wing in the 1980s. The Conservative Party was not very keen on the BBC at times. So by the time the Golf war came about, the BBC was very sensitive about what it did during the war. For example when asked whether they would play the Rolling Stones record High Wire, which is a critique of arms dealers, the head of Radio One at that point said, “No, we won’t play it because we don’t want to be the leftie BBC fighting the enemies of freedom again”. So there was a kind of attack on the BBC. At the same time the commercial networks had just been subject to new legal restraints from the 1990 Broadcast Act. So they kind of censor themselves anyway and they don’t need the state to tell them
So I would argue that popular music at its best probably is when it is resisting and being a dissident voice and during the Golf war that voice wasn’t heard at all. I don’t think you have to be a supporter of Saddam Hussein to hope that at least next time popular music might get more voice and get back its radical tradition.
More from the conference
Gulf War: sensitivity or censorship
During the 1991 Gulf War, BBC, the British Broadcasting Corporation issued a list of records which, according to New Statesman, were not to be played on any of its radio stations. However, as Martin Cloonan explains above, this list of songs was actually not a ‘ban’ as such, it was just a list of records produced which BBC producers and DJ’s might like to consider carefully before playing.
According to New Statesman, 5 April 1991, this was what the reputed list looked like:
10CC – Rubber Bullets ABBA – Waterloo – Under Attack AKA – Hunting High And Low ALARM 68 – Guns ANIMALS – We Got To Get Out Of This Place ARRIVAL – I Will Survive ‘ JOAN BAEZ – The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down BANGLES – Walk Like An Egyptian BEATLES – Back In The USSR PAT BENETAR – Love Is A Battlefield BIG COUNTRY – Fields Of Fire BLONDIE – Atomic BOOMTOWN RATS – I Don’t Like Mondays BROOK BROTHERS – Warpaint CRAZY WORLD OF ARTHUR BROWN – Fire KATE BUSH – Army Dreamers CHER – Bang Bang My Baby Shot Me Down ERIC CLAPTON – I Shot The Sherrif PHIL COLLINS – In The Air Tonight ELVIS COSTELLO – Oliver’s Army CUTTING CREW – I Just Died In Your Arms Tonight SKEETER DAVIS – End Of The World DESMOND DEKKER – Israelites DIRE STRAITS – Brothers In Arms DURAN DURAN – View To A Kill JOSE FELICIANO – Light My Fire FIRST CHOICE – Armed And Extremely Dangerous ROBERTA FLACK – Killing Me Softly With His Song FRANKIE GOES TO HOLLYWOOD – Two Tribes EDDIE GRANT – Living On The Front Line – Give Me Hope Joanna ELTON JOHN – Saturday Night’s Alright For Fighting MILLIE JACKSON – Act Of War J HATES JAZZ – I Don’t Want To Be A Hero JOHN LENNON – Give Peace A Chance – Imagine JONA LEWIS – Stop The Cavalry LULU – Boom Bang A Bang MCGUINNESS FLINT – When I’m Dead And Gone BOB MARLEY – Buffalo Soldier MARIA MULDAUR – Midnight At The Oasis MASH – Suicide Is Painless MIKE AND THE MECHANICS – Silent Running RICK NELSON – Fools Rush In NICOLE – A Little Peace BILLY OCEAN – When The Going Gets Tough DONNY OSMOND – Soldier Of Love PAPER LACE – Billy Don’t Be A Hero QUEEN – Killer Queen – Flash MARTHA REEVES – Forget Me Not B A ROBERTSON – Bang Bang TOM ROBINSON – War Baby KENNY ROGERS – Ruby Don’t Take Your Love To Town SPANDAU BALLET – I’ll Fly For You SPECIALS – Ghost Queen BRUCE SPRINGSTEIN – I’m On Fire EDWIN STARR – War STATUS QUO – In The Army Now – Burnin’ Bridges CAT STEVENS – I’m Gonna Get Me A Gun ROD STEWART – Sailing DONNA SUMMER – State Of Independence TEARS FOR FEARS – Everybody Wants To Rule The World TEMPTATIONS – Ball Of Confusion STEVIE WONDER – Heaven Help Us All
Information source: “The filtered war”, New Statesman, 5 April 1991
Extensive article on how music was “restricted” during the Falkland and Gulf war, with focus on UK legislation and corporate censorship. Presented by Martin Cloonan at the 1st World Conference on Music and Censorship, 1998
Damon Albarn, Tony Allen and Ty on self-censorship, corporate censorship, censorship in Africa, and music during wartime – video excerpts from the Freemuse organized press conference on freedom of musical expression, Roskilde Festival 2003
Small record labels fear more corporate control: “This merger is not about economic necessity in a changing market, it is about the desire to dominate and to control the outlets at media and retail level”
Corporate censor no. 1, or just the market leader? A collection of articles on Clear Channel – including the debate on the infamous list of ‘potentially offensive songs’, which Clear Channel suggested its 1.300 radio stations not to play following the September 11 terrorist attacks in the US
The attacks in America may cause a change of heart in Hollywood, but what of the other arts? And what will be the effect on the creative scene in Britain? From dance to pop, Guardian critics assess the likely impact
They were censored on Top of the Pops and infuriated the National Front in the late 70’s. Now the Gang of Four returns to the stage for a few gigs. Vocalist Jon King claims Gang of Four was banned more than the Sex Pistols
This article poses the question: What would a suitable American popular music response to the events of 9/11 sound like? Read the chapter by Martin Cloonan, from the book “9/11 – The world’s all out of tune”
A collection of articles and background information on Hate Music and the current debate, where Elephant Man and Vybz Kartel, the two controversial reggae acts accused of inciting violence against homosexuals, have been dropped from the UK Mobo Awards show
Reggae star Beenie Man – recently accused of “lyrics that are an incitement to homophobic murder and violence” – has been banned from performing at an MTV concert after gay activists planned a protest over the singer’s past lyrics
The British singer has attacked what he calls a McCarthy-like “era of censorship” in America. Entertainers who speak out against the Bush administration or its policy on Iraq, he claimed, risk scorn and damage to their livelihood
American singer Rickie Lee Jones has attacked the policies of the Bush administration on her latest record – despite the potential risk to her career. “I usually reflect things totally internally. But I think what is happening in America is so disturbing to me, it becomes internal”
Pop music played a crucial role in the national debate over the Vietnam War. By the late 1960’s, radio stations across the country were crackling with blatantly political songs that became mainstream hits
Primal Scream’s new album looks set to be banned in the U.S. – for featuring their controversial song ‘Bomb the Pentagon’. The song, a bitter attack on US foreign policy, was premiered live just before the September 11 terror attacks
The US singer – whose song about so-called American Taliban John Walker Lindh provoked major controversy in the US and resulted in US media calling him “unpatriotic” and even “a traitor” – is set to release an album which criticises the Iraq war